Tale of 5 Cities: Interactive Time-lapse of School-Age Population Changes

Introduction

Over the past decade, the educational landscape in the United States has undergone significant transformations. Metropolitan areas such as Chicago, Dallas-Fort Worth, Los Angeles, New York City, and Phoenix have experienced notable changes in student enrollment numbers, prompting school districts to adjust their infrastructures accordingly. This article examines the trends in declining and increasing enrollments from 2011 to 2024, highlighting specific districts affected by these changes. It analyzes recent responses in terms of school openings and closures, explores enrollment shifts in charter and private schools within these regions, and projects future trends and enrollment risks. Additionally, it incorporates the impact of job growth and economic diversity in each region, recognizing these factors as leading indicators of future enrollment trends.

Interactive Time-lapse

---

Our Family Vision service provides detailed demand and demographic analysis for schools and family-dependent businesses. Click here to for more information.

---

See Profiles of Cities and their Metropolitan Area

Click > to expand

Chicago Metropolitan Area

Declining Enrollment (2011–2024)

Chicago Public Schools (CPS), the third-largest school district in the U.S., has faced a steady decline in student enrollment over the past decade. In the 2011–2012 school year, CPS had approximately 404,000 students. By the 2023–2024 school year, enrollment had decreased to around 320,000 students—a loss of over 84,000 students.

Districts Experiencing Decline

• Chicago Public Schools (CPS): The central district has seen consistent enrollment drops.

• Suburban Districts: Some suburban districts like Proviso Township High Schools have also reported declining numbers.

Factors Contributing to Decline

• Population Shifts: Out migration from the city to suburbs or other states has reduced the number of school-aged children.

• Lower Birth Rates: A decrease in birth rates has led to smaller incoming kindergarten classes.

• Economic Factors: Economic challenges and affordability issues have prompted families to relocate.

• School Choice Options: The rise of charter schools and private education alternatives has diverted students from traditional public schools.

Charter and Private School Enrollment

• Charter Schools:

  • Enrollment in CPS charter schools increased during the early 2010s but has stabilized or slightly declined in recent years due to a cap on new charter schools and growing scrutiny.

    • Example: Noble Network of Charter Schools, one of the largest in Chicago, saw enrollment plateau around 12,000 students.

• Private Schools:

  • Private school enrollment in Chicago has remained relatively stable, with some fluctuations.

  • Catholic schools under the Archdiocese of Chicago have faced closures due to financial challenges and declining enrollment.

Economic Factors: Job Growth and Economic Diversity

• Job Growth:

  • Stagnant Growth: Chicago's job growth has been slower compared to national averages. Between 2011 and 2024, the city experienced modest job growth, with some sectors like technology and healthcare expanding, while traditional manufacturing sectors declined.

  • Unemployment Rates: Chicago has faced higher unemployment rates compared to other major cities, impacting families' economic stability.

• Economic Diversity:

  • Strengths: The city's economy is diversified across finance, technology, manufacturing, and transportation.

  • Challenges: Economic disparities persist, with significant income inequality affecting certain neighborhoods more than others.

    
    

Impact on Enrollment Trends

• Leading Indicator: Slower job growth and economic challenges have contributed to population declines, as families move elsewhere for better opportunities, leading to decreased school enrollments.

• Future Projections:

  • District Schools: Continued enrollment decline is likely if economic conditions do not improve significantly.

  • Charter and Private Schools: May face similar risks due to overall population decreases.

Analysis

Economic factors play a critical role in Chicago's enrollment trends. Without significant job growth and economic revitalization, especially in underserved communities, the district schools may continue to experience enrollment declines. Efforts to stimulate economic development could help retain families and stabilize school enrollments.

Dallas-Fort Worth Metroplex

Increasing Enrollment (2011–2024)

The Dallas-Fort Worth (DFW) area has experienced substantial growth. Student enrollment in many districts within the metroplex has surged due to a booming population.

Districts Experiencing Growth

• Frisco Independent School District (Frisco ISD):

  • Enrollment increased from approximately 37,000 students in 2011 to over 66,000 students in 2024.

• Prosper Independent School District (Prosper ISD):

  • Enrollment grew from around 7,000 students in 2011 to over 23,000 students in 2024.

• Denton Independent School District (Denton ISD):

  • Saw significant growth, with enrollment surpassing 32,000 students.

Factors Driving Growth

• Economic Prosperity: The region's strong economy attracts families seeking employment opportunities.

• Affordable Housing: Compared to other metropolitan areas, DFW offers more affordable living options.

• In-Migration: Domestic migration contributes to population growth.

Charter and Private School Enrollment

• Charter Schools:

  • Uplift Education and IDEA Public Schools have expanded, increasing charter school enrollment in the region.

  • Charter enrollment in Texas grew by approximately 7% annually over the past decade.

• Private Schools:

  • Enrollment in private schools has grown modestly, with schools like The Hockaday School and St. Mark's School of Texas maintaining strong enrollment numbers.

Economic Factors: Job Growth and Economic Diversity

• Job Growth

  • Robust Expansion: DFW has been one of the fastest-growing job markets in the U.S., with significant growth in technology, healthcare, finance, and logistics.

  • Corporate Relocations: Major companies like Toyota, Liberty Mutual, and Charles Schwab have relocated headquarters or significant operations to the area.

    
    

• Economic Diversity

  • Varied Sectors: The Dallas-Fort Worth economy is driven by diverse industries, including aerospace, energy, logistics, and technology. Recent expansions include companies such as Google, which is growing its footprint in the metroplex, and Texas Instruments, which has invested heavily in semiconductor manufacturing in Richardson.

  • Exiting Employers: While most companies are entering, some small-scale manufacturing and retail firms have downsized or relocated due to rising costs in certain suburban areas.

    
    

• Impact on Enrollment Trends

  • Leading Indicator: Robust economic growth and corporate relocations are driving population increases, directly impacting higher school enrollments.

  • Future Projections:

    • District Schools: Continued enrollment increases are expected, with districts like Frisco ISD and Prosper ISD planning additional campuses.

    • Charter and Private Schools: Likely to see growth aligned with the demand for diverse education options and increasing population density.

      
      

Analysis The DFW area's expanding economy and affordable housing market create a favorable environment for enrollment growth. Strategic planning for infrastructure and innovative curriculum offerings will be essential for districts and schools to accommodate the rapid changes.

Los Angeles Metropolitan Area

Declining Enrollment (2011–2024)

Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) has continued its enrollment decline from approximately 662,000 students in 2011 to around 415,000 students in 2024—a decrease of over 247,000 students.

Economic Factors: Job Growth and Major Employers

• Entering Employers:

  • Silicon Beach Expansion: Major technology firms like Amazon Studios, Netflix, and Google have expanded operations in Los Angeles, particularly in the tech and entertainment sectors.

  • Electric Vehicle Manufacturing: Companies such as Rivian and BYD have invested in nearby manufacturing and innovation hubs.

• Exiting Employers:

  • Traditional Manufacturing Declines: Several mid-sized manufacturing firms have relocated to lower-cost regions like Arizona and Nevada.

  • Retail Contractions: High-profile retail closures, such as Macy's and other department stores, have impacted local job markets.

    
    

• Economic Diversity:

  • Strengths: Los Angeles remains a global hub for entertainment, trade, and technology. However, job growth is concentrated in high-skill sectors, creating barriers for middle-income families.

  • Challenges: The high cost of living continues to drive out families, reducing the number of school-aged children.

  
  

• Impact on Enrollment Trends

  • Leading Indicator: Economic pressures and high housing costs continue to drive population decline, especially among families with school-aged children.

  • Future Projections:

    • District Schools: Enrollment declines are expected to persist unless affordability issues are addressed.

    • Charter Schools: Enrollment may stabilize due to specialized offerings, but overall growth is limited by the declining population.

      
      

Analysis Los Angeles faces unique challenges in retaining families due to economic disparities. Initiatives addressing affordability, equitable job growth, and housing may help stabilize school enrollments.

New York City Metropolitan Area

Declining Enrollment (2011–2024)

New York City public schools have seen enrollment fall from about 1.1 million students in 2011 to approximately 900,000 students in 2024.

Economic Factors: Job Growth and Major Employers

• Entering Employers:

  • Tech Growth: Companies like Google, Meta, and Amazon have expanded operations in New York, creating jobs in technology and media.

  • Life Sciences Investments: Firms such as Illumina and Regeneron Pharmaceuticals have increased their presence, supported by state initiatives.

    
    

• Exiting Employers:

  • Banking Sector Reductions: Some mid-sized financial institutions have downsized or moved operations to lower-cost cities like Charlotte or Atlanta.

  • Retail Closures: Continued store closures across Manhattan and boroughs have reduced employment opportunities.

    
    

• Economic Diversity:

  • Strengths: The economy spans finance, technology, healthcare, and media. Investments in life sciences and green energy also show promise.

  • Challenges: The city remains one of the most expensive places to live, with affordability issues driving out middle-income families.

    
    

• Impact on Enrollment Trends

  • Leading Indicator: Economic opportunities exist, but high living costs and pandemic-related population shifts have led to declining school enrollments.

    
    

  • Future Projections:

    • District Schools: Enrollment is likely to decline further unless cost-of-living issues are addressed.

    • Charter and Private Schools: Elite institutions may maintain or slightly grow enrollment, while smaller schools face risks.

      
      

Analysis New York City offers diverse economic opportunities, but systemic issues related to affordability may continue to challenge public school enrollments.

Phoenix Metropolitan Area

Increasing Enrollment (2011–2024)

Phoenix has remained one of the fastest-growing metropolitan areas, with student enrollment rising across public, charter, and private schools.

Economic Factors: Job Growth and Major Employers

• Entering Employers:

  • Semiconductor Investments: Taiwan Semiconductor Manufacturing Company (TSMC) and Intel have made significant investments, creating thousands of jobs.

  • Logistics and E-commerce Growth: Companies like Amazon and Walmart have expanded their distribution networks in the region.

    
    

• Exiting Employers:

  • Limited Exits: The region has experienced minimal major employer losses due to its business-friendly policies and affordable living costs.

    
    

• Economic Diversity:

  • Strengths: Phoenix's economy has diversified into technology, manufacturing, and logistics, reducing reliance on traditional industries.

  • Challenges: Rapid growth creates infrastructure challenges, including school overcrowding and transportation needs.

    
    

• Impact on Enrollment Trends

  • Leading Indicator: Economic growth and affordable housing attract families, contributing to increased school enrollments.

  • Future Projections:

    • District Schools: Expected to grow, with many districts adding new campuses.

    • Charter Schools: Likely to see continued growth due to Arizona's strong support for school choice.

    • Private Schools: May benefit from voucher programs and population increases.

      
      

Analysis Phoenix's economic environment supports strong enrollment growth across educational sectors. Strategic planning to address infrastructure needs is critical for sustaining this growth.

Comparative Insights

Economic Drivers Across Markets

• Chicago: Economic stagnation and population outflows remain key challenges.

• Dallas-Fort Worth: Corporate relocations and a thriving job market fuel rapid growth.

• Los Angeles: Economic disparity and high costs continue to drive families away.

• New York City: While job opportunities are strong, affordability remains a significant barrier.

• Phoenix: Rapid job growth and affordability make it a standout for population and enrollment increases.